
Guest Post: Republicans Cannot Scapegoat Their Way Back to Victory
Editor’s Note: Robert Sinners currently serves in the Georgia Secretary of State’s office under Brad Raffensperger. He previously served as Election Day Operations Director for Donald Trump’s 2020 presidential campaign. The views expressed in this guest column are his own.
In the aftermath of a consequential, if not generational wipeout, Republicans are searching for answers.
Unfortunately, some seem more interested in finding someone to blame.
The latest theory is that Senate Republicans, particularly Majority Leader John Thune, failed to deliver on President Trump’s agenda, leaving frustrated supporters at home on Election Day.
Republican National Committeewoman Amy Kremer recently admonished Senate Republicans for making excuses instead of keeping their promises, calling for passage of the SAVE America Act and confirmation of Trump’s nominees. Conservative election activist Cleta Mitchell went considerably further, accusing Thune of doing nothing to advance the legislation, prioritizing K Street lobbyists over election integrity, and allowing America’s election system to be manipulated by the left. Declaring that “Tuesday was the Thune election,” Mitchell placed responsibility for the Republican defeat squarely on the Senate Majority Leader.
Those frustrations deserve to be heard. But frustration is not evidence of causation, especially when it becomes an exercise in scapegoating.
I say this as someone who served as Election Day Operations Director for Trump’s 2020 campaign and subsequently spent six years working for Georgia Secretary of State Brad Raffensperger. I’ve experienced elections from both sides: the campaign war room and the government office responsible for administering them.
And I’ve learned something important: Blaming someone else for losing an election is considerably easier than admitting why you lost.
Consider what voters actually told pollsters.
An October Pew Research Center survey found that 84 percent of registered voters considered the economy very important to their vote. Healthcare, immigration, and the future of democracy also ranked prominently. Gallup similarly found the economy, healthcare, and the situation in Iran leading voters’ concerns.
The SAVE Act wasn’t separately measured in those surveys. That doesn’t mean voters didn’t care about it. But it provides no evidence that failure to pass it was the decisive reason Republicans lost.
Meanwhile, voters could see and hear the leader of the free world discussing his own priorities: a reflecting pool, a triumphal arch, a ballroom, and being nice to Russia.
While Americans worried about groceries, healthcare, gasoline, and the direction of the economy, the president devoted considerable public attention to grand architectural projects and monuments to his own presidency.
A White House ballroom may be an interesting architectural undertaking. A triumphal arch may someday be a Washington landmark. But neither is going to make a family’s mortgage payment or lower the price of groceries.
If someone has polling demonstrating that millions of Republicans stayed home specifically because John Thune failed to pass the SAVE Act, I’d genuinely like to see it.
Until then, we should be skeptical of explanations that conveniently absolve the most powerful Republican in America of responsibility for his own party’s performance.
President Trump has never been particularly reluctant to assign blame. But the presidency comes with responsibility for setting the national agenda, communicating priorities, and governing. Just because things aren’t going your way doesn’t mean you aren’t responsible for them.
Nor can John Thune reasonably be held responsible for every decision about what the White House chooses to emphasize.
There is a broader lesson here.
In 2020, I watched what happened when Republicans became more interested in explaining away an election defeat than confronting reality. In the years that followed, working for Secretary Raffensperger, I saw firsthand the enormous institutional and personal costs of that refusal.
I have no interest in watching Republicans repeat the exercise.
There are fair criticisms to make of congressional leadership, legitimate questions about legislative priorities, missed opportunities, and whether Republicans delivered on their promises.
But a serious post-election examination must also place the president’s decisions, the administration’s policies, economic conditions, candidate quality, and the concerns of voters who supported Republicans in 2024 but chose differently in 2026 at the forefront.
A political party cannot learn from an election if every explanation begins with the assumption that its leader bears no responsibility.
The SAVE Act deserves a debate on its merits. John Thune deserves scrutiny for his record. And Donald Trump deserves to be held accountable for his own.
Republicans should demand evidence before accepting any single explanation for their defeat.
Because the first step toward understanding why voters rejected your candidates is listening to what those voters actually said, not simply what the loudest voices in your own party want to believe.
